2, మార్చి 2012, శుక్రవారం

Slow down in the economy--The remedy is more dangerous than the disease


Alarming slowdown of the economic growth

The growth rate of the GDP(Gross Domestic Product) of India slipped to 6.1 per cent in the Q3(third quarter, that is October to December 2011) of 2011-12 against the 8.3 per cent growth rate witnessed in the same period, October-December 2010. This is the 6th time that the growth rate declined, in the last 7 quarters. This proves the seriousness of the economic slowdown. The worrying factor is that the growth rate in manufacturing sector fell down to 0.4 per cent in October-December 2011 against 7.8 per cent during the same period in 2010. Thus there is virtually no growth in the manufacturing sector.  The mining sector witnessed a  drastic slow down with a growth rate of 3.1 per cent in October –December 2011 compared to the same period in 2010. Despite a bumper harvest, said to be due to the effect of a higher growth in 2010, stood at 2.7 percent during October –December 2011 compared to 11 per cent in the same period in 2010. The growth rate of GDP as a whole for the period  April-December 2011 is 6.9 per cent compared to 8.1 percent during the same period in 2010. The growth rate in construction sector fell down to 7.2 per cent in October-December 2011 as compared to the 8.7 per cent growth rate during the same period in 2010. The services sector ( IT, telecom services, tourism, hotels, etc) also witnessed a slow down with a growth rate of 9.9 per cent in October-December 2011 compared to the 11.2 per cent growth during the same period in 2012.  The actual growth rate for 2011-12 could even be lower than the 6.9 per cent predicted by the Government. (In 2010-11, the growth rate was 8.4 per cent).  

The wrong reasons mentioned by Corporates

 The Corporate news papers are mentioning the following   factors as the reasons for this slow down in the economy:
a)      The Reserve Bank increased the interest rates to curtail inflation (Meaning it prevented circulation of more money by increasing interest rates). It acted as a disincentive for investing in industries by taking loan. Thus it reduced the confidence of the investor!

b)      Continued hike in the international oil prices resulted in increasing the cost and reducing the profit and hence acted as a disincentive for the investors


c)       The demand for goods was slack at home and abroad. Due to the slowdown of the economies of the advanced capitalist countries, exports to those countries suffered.

The wrong prescription by the Corporates and their ideologues

Basing their argument on the above said factors, the Corporate media, the economists favoring the Corporates are prescribing the lowering of interest rates by the Reserve Bank so that the Corporates will get bank loans at reduced interest rates and hence invest more in industries and will thus help the growth. The various Associations representing the Corporates like CII(Confederation of Indian Industries), FICCI (Federation Of Indian Chambers Of Commerce and Industries), ASSOCHAM (Associated  Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India) are demanding the Government to implement reforms in a fast manner for increasing the growth of the economy. The reforms they want are reducing the interest rates, allowing more and more FDI, reducing the taxes and duties on the Corporates and allowing them to take over the assets of the PSUs and the natural resources  at throw away prices.  They are also pressurizing the Government to allow more and more space to the Corporates in the agriculture. The sum and substance of these proposals is that the Corporates should be granted more and more incentives to encourage them to produce more.
But these Corporates, their media and the economists supporting them are thinking about the supply side only and forgetting about the demand side. The slow down in the economy is due to the slow down in the demand ultimately. The slow down in the demand is due to the reduced purchasing power available with the vast majority of the population. Without strengthening the demand, what is the use of producing, when what will be produced will not be purchased?

The prescription of the Working Class

Hence against these demands of the Corporates and their pen pushers aimed to loot the economy, the central trade unions have suggested the following measures in their meeting with the Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee on 16th January 2012:

1.       Stop the price rise of essential commodities by banning the speculation and forward trading in the essential commodities and by strengthening the public distribution system and by reducing the prices of the petroleum products.
2.       Remove the ban on recruitment and provide employment. Link the stimulus package given to the Corporates with the conditions for banning retrenchment, lay offs, closures, wage cuts and job cuts.

3.       Statutory minimum wages be ensured to the crores of the workers in the unorganized sector.

4.       The MNREGA(Mahatma Gandhi Rural Employment Guarantee Act) be extended to urban areas and 200 days employment in a year be ensured along with provision of statutory  minimum wages

5.       The PSUs are having a cash reserve of Rs 6 lakh crores. They should be allowed to utilize these reserves for their expansion and development so that more jobs are created.There should be no disinvestment of PSUs.

6.       The proposed reforms in banking and insurance sector for allowing more and more FDI thereby causing danger to the stability of our financial system should be withdrawn.

7.       Budgetary support should be given to the traditional sectors like jute, textiles, plantations, handloom, coir etc.

8.       The rate of interest on EPF, GPF and savings by ordinary people  etc should be enhanced.All should be ensured pension in their old age.

9.       Income tax exemption for salried persons should be raised to Rsx 3 lakhs per annum and fring benefits like housing, medical and educational facuilities should be exempted from the income tax in totality.


10.   The resources for all these activities be raised by increasing duties on imported power plant equipments, imposing wind fall tax on petroleum products exported from stand alone refineries, increasing the taxes on the rich and affluent sections having the capacity to pay a higher taX. The Corporate service sector, traders, wholesale business, private hospitals and institutions should be brought under  broader and higher tax net. The export duty on iron ore exports should be increased. Effective measures should be taken to unearth the huge accumulation of black money within and outside the country. The huge amount of Rs 3 lakh crores unpaid tax from the Corporates should be collected. The huge tax concessions given to the Corporates should be stopped. The huge amount of unpaid loans should be collected  from the Corporates by the Nationalized Banks. Serrvice Tax should be imposed on ITES, outsourcing sector, educational institutions and health services running on commercial basis.

Similarly it is also necessary to help the peasants by extending loans at reduced interest rates, by investing more for developing irrigation, by ensuring remunerative prices to their products etc.

If these steps favoring the workers, peasants and common people are taken, it will result in increasing their purchasing capacity and hence the demand. If the demand is thus increased, there will be growth in the market and hence the scope for growth in the economy.

The attitude of the Government

But the Government under the pressure of the Indian and foreign big corporate is not going to consider the demands of the trade unions and peasants, except announcing some small concessions here and there in the coming budget and propagate it as a pro-people measure. The main thrust of the budget will be to favor the Corporates at the cost of the people and it will result in further slow down in the economy and consequent hardships to the workers and peasants. The remedy prescribed by the Corporates and their ideologists is more dangerous than the disease.

Struggles against the wrong policies should be intensified to save the economy

The struggles against these pro-corporate policies should be further broadened and strengthened to change these policies and to ensure healthy growth of the economy.

1 కామెంట్‌: